| Ida Eleanor Hagenbuch | 18 Jun 1857 | 7 Apr 1934 |
| Isaac K. Hagenbuch | 16 Jun 1860 | 29 Sep 1860 |
| Isabella (Hagenbuch) Correy | 12 Aug 1861 | |
| Isaiah H. Hagenbuch | 6 Mar 1844 | 6 Nov 1910 |
| J. B. Hagenbuch | 15 Feb 1843 | 31 May 1843 |
| John "Jack" Andrew Hagenbuch | 11 Dec 1857 | 7 Apr 1923 |
| John Ruckle Hagenbuch | Feb 1860 | 18 Feb 1941 |
| John Vance Hagenbuch | 12 Mar 1845 | 23 Jan 1917 |
| John W. Hagenbuch | 2 Mar 1841 | 16 Mar 1875 |
| John W. Hagenbucher | 1841 | 1933 |
| Joseph Hagenbuch | 19 May 1858 | 13 Sep 1858 |
| Joseph "Joe" Hagenbuch | 1859 | 1899 |
| Joseph D. Hagenbuch | 8 Nov 1845 | 14 Jul 1847 |
| Lavina Hagenbuch | 1841 | |
| Levi Peter Hagenbuch | 21 Aug 1857 | |
| Lewis E. Hagenbuch | 9 Jan 1860 | 18 Feb 1864 |
| Lizzie Hagenbuch | 14 May 1861 | 14 May 1861 |
| Lovina (Petry) Hagenbuch | 25 Aug 1841 | 26 Oct 1926 |
| Lucie Elizabeth (Taylor) Hagenbuch | 21 Sep 1857 | 10 Feb 1928 |
| Lucinda (Hagenbuch) Brobst | 2 Mar 1845 | 23 Mar 1898 |