| Sarah M. Hagenbuch | 1862 | 1947 |
| Sarah "Sally" Marie (Hagenbuch) DeMartini | 28 Jan 1949 | 22 Jul 2021 |
| Sarah Salome (Bauman/Bowman) Hagenbuch | 25 Mar 1808 | 4 Sep 1891 |
| Sarah Winifred (Randolph) Hagenbuch | 6 May 1903 | 7 Sep 1986 |
| Scott Hagenbuch | | |
| Scott Brian Hagenbuch | | |
| Scott Thomas Hagenbuch | | |
| Sheila Veronica (Fitzgerald) Hagenbuch | | |
| Sheryl Louise Hagenbuch | | |
| Shirley Ardele Hagenbuch | 23 May 1944 | 10 Mar 2014 |
| Shirley Baird (Hagenbuch) Michael | 26 Mar 1919 | 17 Dec 2017 |
| Shirley Marie (Gresh) Hagenbuch | 16 Dec 1934 | 3 Dec 2012 |
| Shirlie Jean (Hagenbuch) Lowe | 28 Sep 1927 | 24 Feb 2011 |
| Silas Benjamin Hagenbuch | | |
| Simon Hagenbuch | 26 Feb 1910 | 10 Aug 1910 |
| Simon Hagenbuch | 4 Jul 1788 | 10 Sep 1858 |
| Solomon D. B. Hagenbuch | 26 Feb 1831 | 23 May 1873 |
| Solomon Dentler Hagenbuch, Sgt. | 9 Feb 1838 | 16 Jun 1864 |
| Sondra "Sunny" Vee (Hagenbuch) Mertz | | |
| Sophia (Hoch) Hagenbuch | 12 May 1840 | 10 Jun 1916 |