| Bertha Hagenbaugh | 10 Dec 1886 | 10 Aug 1887 |
| Betty June (Preslar) Hagenbush | 27 Jun 1928 | 13 Feb 2015 |
| Bonnie Jean Hagenbaugh | 27 Sep 1921 | 18 Feb 2008 |
| Caleb Hagenbaugh | 1828 | 2 Apr 1865 |
| Caroline "Carrie" Etta (Mauck) Hagenbuck | 28 Dec 1865 | 1943 |
| Catharine (Smith) Hagenbaugh | 1815 | 20 Jun 1888 |
| Catherine (Heckman) Hagenbaugh | 29 Dec 1811 | 20 Oct 1895 |
| Catherine Hagenbaugh | 1818 | 7 Jul 1883 |
| Catherine "Karen" (Clark) Hagenbaugh | 28 Aug 1820 | 18 Jan 1910 |
| Catherine "Kay" J. (Hagenbaugh) Broderick | 1922 | 1970 |
| Charles F. Hagenbaugh | 23 Sep 1888 | 10 Dec 1918 |
| Charles Kevin Hagenbush | | |
| Charles M. Hagenbaugh | 19 Feb 1863 | 4 Apr 1924 |
| Charles M. Hagenbook | 28 Jan 1882 | |
| Charles Pershing Hagenbaugh, Sr. | 18 Mar 1919 | 20 Dec 2005 |
| Charles "Chuck" Pershing Hagenbaugh, Jr. | | |
| Charles "Charly" R. Hagenbaugh | 5 May 1881 | 4 Dec 1881 |
| Charles "Red" Richard Hagenbush | 26 Jun 1928 | 11 May 2016 |
| Charles "Jake" Robert Hagenbush | | |
| Charles William Hagenbaugh | 27 Feb 1863 | 31 May 1913 |