| Christian Oliver Hagenbaugh | 8 Mar 1834 | 5 Nov 1901 |
| Christina M. (Stoetzner) Hagenbaugh | 11 Jun 1880 | 11 Aug 1966 |
| Clarence Edward Hagenbaugh | 13 Mar 1887 | |
| Corene (Hagenbush ) Grossman | 14 Feb 1901 | 4 Nov 1980 |
| Cornelia Hagenbaugh | 1875 | 1962 |
| Cornelius Hagenbaugh, Cpl. | Sep 1830 | 26 Jun 1905 |
| Donald Lee Hagenbush | 9 Jul 1929 | 2 Nov 2016 |
| Dorothy Louise (Hagenbaugh) Abreu | 9 Sep 1913 | 8 Mar 2008 |
| Dorothy May (Manning) Hagenbaugh | 15 May 1912 | 19 May 2007 |
| Earl Olin Hagenbuck | 14 Sep 1875 | 20 Feb 1952 |
| Earl Scott Hagenbaugh | 14 Apr 1882 | 26 Apr 1946 |
| Edith May (Hagenbaugh) Green | 24 Apr 1879 | |
| Edwin LeRoy Hagenbaugh | 3 Sep 1888 | |
| Eliza (Zerbe) Hagenbaugh | 20 Jan 1815 | 19 Mar 1900 |
| Elizabeth (Wirtz) Hagenbach | 7 Dec 1887 | 11 Dec 1914 |
| Elizabeth "Betsey" (Marvin) Hagenbaugh | 11 Oct 1818 | 4 May 1845 |
| Ella E. Hagenbaugh | 1881 | 1925 |
| Ella "Earlmeda" Earlmeda (Hagenbaugh) McQuesten | 9 Oct 1908 | 21 Dec 1970 |
| Elmira (Hagenbaugh) Musser | 30 Aug 1839 | 14 Nov 1896 |
| Emillie "Millie/Mrs. G." Lydia (Hagenbook) Kitchell | 11 Oct 1863 | 30 Jul 1942 |