| Mary Ann (Cochran) Hagenbuck | 27 Feb 1809 | 29 May 1881 |
| Mary Anna (Katz) Hagenbaugh | 31 Oct 1837 | 22 Feb 1923 |
| Mary E. (Kleiner) Hagenbach | 1884 | |
| Mary Lenora (Hagenbaugh) Wick | 5 Sep 1885 | 11 Oct 1963 |
| Mary Ophelia (Kipp) Hagenbaugh | 1815 | 12 Jun 1887 |
| Maude (Hagenbuck) Francis | 11 Oct 1864 | 16 Sep 1905 |
| May E. Hagenbach | 1 May 1879 | 3 Oct 1925 |
| Mildred "Millie" Grace (Gentry) Hagenbaugh | 25 May 1908 | 30 Jun 1989 |
| Mildred Lois (Hagenbaugh) McDade | 9 Sep 1918 | |
| Minerva "Mary" (Williamson) Hagenbaugh | 1815 | 16 Sep 1869 |
| Minerva "Minnie" (Hagenbaugh) Nourse | 10 Oct 1863 | 31 Jul 1894 |
| Minnie Hagenbaugh | 1868 | 1868 |
| Miriam L. (Kleppinger) Hagenbach | 16 Jul 1885 | 12 Feb 1961 |
| Nancy Hagenbaugh | 1838 | |
| Nellie M. Hagenbuck | 26 Sep 1869 | 26 Oct 1889 |
| Neva (Hagenbach) Welter | 1912 | 26 Jul 2008 |
| Nora (Hagenbook) Cornwell | 3 Dec 1871 | 19 Jul 1951 |
| Owen L. Hagenbuck | 16 Aug 1897 | 27 Sep 1897 |
| Pearle Louise (Hagenbaugh) Rauenzahn | 7 May 1890 | 1961 |
| Phebe "Pheba" Ann (Youngs) Hagenbaugh | 18 Apr 1814 | 5 Jun 1870 |