| Connie Sue (Cummings) Hagenbuch | | |
| Crystal (Kremer) Hagenbuch | | |
| Cyndi Hagenbuch | | |
| Cynthia Hagenbuch | | |
| Cyrenas S. Hagenbaugh | 1851 | 1922 |
| Darlene E. (Rohlfing) Hagenbuch | | |
| David Hagenbuch | | |
| David George Hagenbuch, Jr. | | |
| Deborah Hagenbuch | | |
| Deborah (Hagenbuch) Motter | | |
| Debra Hagenbuch | | |
| Dennis "Nick" Gideon Hagenbaugh | 1851 | |
| Diane Hagenbuch | | |
| Dolores Ann (Hagenbuch) Scholl | | |
| Donald Allen Hagenbuch | | |
| Donna Hagenbuch | | |
| Donna (Erdman) Hagenbuch | | |
| Doris Hagenbuch | | |
| Dorothy "Dot" (Straukas) Hagenbuch | | |
| Edna (Fisher) Hagenbuch | | |