| Susannah "Susan" (Freese) Hagenbush | 17 Sep 1847 | 6 Nov 1882 |
| William Hagenbuck | 24 Jan 1846 | 25 Sep 1927 |
| Winfield Scott Hagenbaugh | 26 Oct 1847 | 26 Aug 1880 |
| Anna Rebecca (Hagenbaugh) Thomas | 22 Apr 1842 | 11 May 1930 |
| Carrie Jane (Hagenbuck) Obenchain | 17 Apr 1859 | 4 Aug 1914 |
| Charles W. Hagenbaugh | 13 Jan 1857 | 22 Dec 1937 |
| Christian "Christopher" Hagenbaugh | 1841 | 1899 |
| Emma Alice (Hagenbaugh) Blaylock | 4 Mar 1860 | 6 Jul 1930 |
| Eola Hagenbaugh | 11 Dec 1860 | 10 Jul 1861 |
| Georgeanne Hagenbaugh | 1857 | |
| Henry C. Hagenbaugh | 1843 | 1869 |
| Henry H. Hagenbuck | Apr 1843 | 4 Jan 1926 |
| Hiram P. Hagenbaugh | 22 Jun 1842 | 10 Feb 1859 |
| Isadore (Clark) Hagenbuck | 1844 | 9 Sep 1908 |
| John H. Hagenbush | Aug 1845 | 2 Jul 1908 |
| Louisa (Kepler) Hagenbush | 1845 | 30 Apr 1912 |
| Lydia Ann (Barr) Hagenbaugh | 1 Nov 1857 | 23 Dec 1930 |
| Margaret J. (Pickerl) Hagenbush | 1 Aug 1843 | 15 Mar 1906 |
| Mary Ann Hagenbuck | 1843 | |
| Mary E. Hagenbaugh | 1845 | |