Marriage date is circa. Appears on the 1900 census as “Howard C. Tubbs” a boarder, age 5, with William and Mary Alice Hagenbaugh. This doesn’t make sense. It also shows that the person he lists as his mother, has had 0 children (recorded for the year 1900 of the census). Howard must be staying with them or have been adopted, then he later took the family name. William Hagenbaugh and Alice Long are listed as his parents on his death certificate. His biological parents are currently unknown. Listed on Findagrave.1