| Lucie Elizabeth (Taylor) Hagenbuch | 21 Sep 1857 | 10 Feb 1928 |
| Lucinda (Hagenbuch) Brobst | 2 Mar 1845 | 23 Mar 1898 |
| Margaret Alice (Hagenbuch) Hagenbuch | 28 Sep 1843 | 5 Sep 1893 |
| Maria (Frye) Hagenbuch | 15 Sep 1842 | 1 Nov 1903 |
| Marsella A. (Yost) Hagenbuch | 4 Dec 1858 | 13 May 1882 |
| Martha (Kehr) Hagenbuch | 17 Sep 1860 | 24 Sep 1932 |
| Martha E. (Hagenbuch) Sipe | 1861 | 1885 |
| Martha Jane (Best) Hagenbuch | 9 Jun 1859 | 9 Dec 1918 |
| Martha Melick (Hagenbuch) Hiles | 16 Feb 1857 | 4 Oct 1911 |
| Martha "Mattie" N. (Hagenbuch) Eckels | 4 Sep 1844 | 4 Dec 1916 |
| Martha S. (Hagenbuch) Scouten | 5 Sep 1844 | 25 Jan 1928 |
| Mary Hagenbuch | 1843 | |
| Mary (Hawk) Hagenbuch | 4 Oct 1842 | 13 Sep 1925 |
| Mary Ann (Hagenbuch) Foust | 29 Oct 1842 | 10 Jan 1904 |
| Mary C. (Hagenbuch) Ludwig | 8 Dec 1858 | 16 Mar 1950 |
| Mary Elizabeth (Savage) Hagenbuch | 8 Mar 1858 | 10 Jul 1913 |
| Mary Ella (Hagenbuch) Harris | 18 Jul 1845 | 25 Dec 1903 |
| Mary "Nellie" Ellen (Harwood) Hagenbuch | 1857 | 1935 |
| Mary Emma (Robbins) Hagenbuch | 30 Jul 1860 | 15 Apr 1943 |
| Mary Jane (Hidlay) Hagenbuch | 24 Sep 1857 | 18 Apr 1889 |