| Caroline (Hagenbucher) Leuz | 1832 | 3 Jan 1904 |
| Caroline (Hagenbuch) Shuman | 1838 | 26 Jul 1893 |
| Caroline Amelia (Hagenbuch) Arndt | 1834 | 3 Jun 1897 |
| Carolyn (Thurlow) Hagenbuch | 26 Jul 1907 | 8 Mar 1995 |
| Carolyn "Lyn" Jean (Hagenbuch) Best | | |
| Carrie Hagenbuch | 17 Aug 1874 | |
| Carrie Hagenbuch | | |
| Carrie A. Hagenbuch | 30 Jun 1873 | 27 Apr 1921 |
| Carrie A. (Hagenbuch) Rehrig | 30 Oct 1913 | 7 Mar 2001 |
| Carrie C. (Everett) Hagenbuch | 1874 | 1948 |
| Carrie Mabel (Bretney) Hagenbuch | 13 Sep 1885 | 25 Oct 1965 |
| Carrie Mable (Beaver) Hagenbuch | 14 Dec 1896 | 20 Mar 1981 |
| Carrie S. (Hagenbuch) Trumpower | 18 Sep 1892 | 26 Aug 1963 |
| Carrie Virginia (Welliver) Hagenbuch | 8 Oct 1931 | 6 Feb 2021 |
| Catharina (Hagenbuch) Brouss | 1739 | 1796 |
| Catharine (Seip) Hagenbuch | 15 Feb 1803 | 12 Aug 1861 |
| Catharine (Scholl) Hagenbuch | 2 Oct 1806 | 16 Nov 1870 |
| Catharine (Heckman) Hagenbuch | 3 Aug 1831 | 19 Jul 1883 |
| Catherine (Hagenbuch) Butz | 1808 | 11 Dec 1885 |
| Catherine (Hagenbuch) Craig | 12 Mar 1803 | 26 Nov 1871 |