| Sarah Louisa (Scholl) Hagenbuch | 26 Jan 1846 | 15 Jan 1934 |
| Sarah R. (Hagenbuch) Maidens | 9 Nov 1846 | 1 Feb 1882 |
| Simon J. P. Hagenbuch | 6 Oct 1846 | 26 Sep 1928 |
| Susan "Matura" Matura (Hagenbuch) Mills | 16 Oct 1856 | 25 Oct 1916 |
| Torinda Salome (Hagenbuch) Richie | 15 Apr 1856 | 24 May 1938 |
| Unknown Hagenbuch | 4 Mar 1856 | 6 Mar 1856 |
| William Allen (Hagenbuch) Hagenbaugh | 26 Aug 1855 | 14 Feb 1937 |
| William Cephis Hagenbuch | 8 Apr 1846 | 22 Jan 1925 |
| William Henry Hagenbuch | 7 Apr 1846 | 18 May 1887 |
| Albert Ira Hagenbuch, Sr. | 2 Feb 1859 | 29 Jul 1931 |
| Amanda H. (Hagenbuch) Wilcox | 23 Aug 1845 | |
| Ambrose Hagenbuch | 1861 | 19 Apr 1937 |
| Anna "Phoebe" K. (Hagenbuch) Lehew | 6 Jun 1845 | 29 Nov 1904 |
| Anna M. (Black) Hagenbuch | 1843 | |
| Anna "Annie" Mary (Hagenbuch) Overdorf | 4 Jun 1842 | 1 Dec 1911 |
| Benjamin L. Hagenbuch | 26 Aug 1841 | 10 Apr 1883 |
| Bertha May (Hagenbuch) Erieg | 1 May 1858 | 25 Jan 1912 |
| Bion William Hagenbuch | 20 Jan 1860 | 18 Jan 1928 |
| Caroline (Hagenbuch) Billman | 5 Dec 1860 | 23 Apr 1922 |
| Caroline (Hagenbuch) Hunsberger | 26 Jun 1844 | 12 Jun 1918 |